Transcript
Competitive Matrix: AT-AR450S -v- other manufacturers MANUFACTURER PRODUCT NAME
Allied Telesyn AR450S
Cisco 831
Cisco 1751
Cisco 1721
Nokia IP380
Nokia IP530
Watchguard Firebox® V60L
Pricing Web page Datasheet (PDF)
www.alliedtelesyn.com
http://Cisco 831 pricing www.cisco.com Cisco 800 Series Routers
http://Cisco 1751 pricing www.cisco.com www.cisco.com/1751
http://Cisco 1721 pricing www.cisco.com www.cisco.com/1721
http://Nokia IP380 pricing www.nokia.com www.nokia.com/IP380
http://Nokia IP530 pricing www.nokia.com www.nokia.com/IP530
https://Firebox V60L pricing www.watchguard.com http://v60l.asp
Size Dimensions (cm) (H x W x D) Weight (kg)
1.5U rack mountable 40.5 x 30.5 x 19 1.75
51 x 97 x 85 0.68
10 x 28.4 x 22.1 1.36
78.5 x 28.4 x 22.1 1.32
45 x 44 x 41 7.7
9 x 44 x 41 15
4.4 x 43.8 x 33.4 4.9
Temperature Operating temperature Storage temperature Humidity
0º to 40ºC -25º to 75ºC 5% to 95%, non-condensing
0º to 40ºC -20º to 65ºC 10% to 85%, non-condensing
0º to 40ºC -20º to 65ºC 5% to 95%, non-condensing
0º to 40ºC -20º to 60ºC 10% to 85%, non-condensing
5º to 40ºC
5º to 45ºC
5º to 45ºC
10% to 90%, non-condensing
10% to 90%, non-condensing
Interfaces LAN 10/100 Ports LAN Connectivity WAN Ports
5 Fast Ethernet 10/100TX 1
4 Ethernet 10T 1
4 Ethernet 10T, Fast Ethernet 1
1 Fast Ethernet 10/100 2
T1/E1, Fractional T1/E1, Channelised T1/E1, ISDN-BRI, Sync Serial, Async Serial, Low Speed Async (115.2kbps) DSL Yes
T1/E1, Fractional T1/E1, ISDN, BRI, Sync Serial, Async Serial, Low Speed Async (115.2kbps) DSL 0
4 Ethernet 10T 3 CPCI Interface slots, 2 type II PCMCIA slots, 1 internal PMC slot (for VPN acceleration) TE/E1 with CSU/DSU, ISDN-BRI
4 Fast Ethernet 10/100 2
Ethernet 10T
4 Ethernet 10T 2 option slots supporting WAN cards or dual port Ethernet for up to 8 total 10/100 ports ISDN-BRI
0
0
0
Aux Port up to 115.2kbps
Aux Port up to 115.2kbps
Aux Port up to 115.2kbps
1 WAN card, 2 Voice/Fax Interface cards, Ethernet Interface Card
2 WIC slots
Dual port 10/100 Ethernet, Single port serial V.35/X.21, 1 port ISDN (EMEA only)
VPN Encryption Module
Hardware-assisted encryption on motherboard
VPN Encryption Chip
Quad port 10/100 Ethernet, T1/E1 with CSU/DSU, Single and dual port serival V.35/X21, HSSI, ATM Multi-Mode Fibre, External Modem, ISDN-BRI VPN Encryption Chip
Yes
Yes 600Mbps (max.) 90Mbps (SHA1-3DES)
507Mbps (max.) 18Mbps (SHA1-3DES)
100Mbps 50Mbps (VPN 3DES throughput)
WAN Connectivity
DMZ Port(s) Auto MDI-X Asynchronous Ports Asynchronous Serial Data Rates
1 Yes 2x V.24 DB9 up to 115kbps
Interface Options Interface Options
Not available
Encryption
0 Yes Aux Port up to 115.2kbps
Hardware-assisted encryption VPN throughput (2Mbps aggregate with IMIX traffic)
Encryption Module LED Indicator Firewall/NAT PPPoE throughput 3DES throughput
32 bit PCI interface to connect to the Ethernet controllers and encryption accelerator Not supported 100Mbps 65Mbps
Power AC input voltage Frequency
100V to 240vAC 50 to 60Hz
100V to 250vAC 50 to 60Hz
100V to 240vAC 47 to 64Hz
100V to 240vAC 47 to 64Hz
100V to 240vAC 50 to 60Hz
100V to 240vAC 50 to 60Hz
100V to 240vAC 50 to 60Hz
Hardware CPU Processor DRAM (default/maximum) Flash (default/maximum)
MPC8435 CPU 400MHz 56MB/256MB 16MB/32MB
Motorola RISC 32MB/48MB 12MB/16MB
MPC860P CPU 48MHz 32MB/96MB 16MB
MPC860P CPU 48MHz 32MB/96MB 16MB
Pentium III 866Mhz 256MB/1024MB
Pentium III 700MHz 256MB/512MB
64MB
Routing RIP v1/v2 OSPF v2 BGP4
Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes OSPF Yes
Yes OSPF Yes
Yes Yes Optional
Yes Yes Optional
Tunnelling Protocols GRE L2TP
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes OSPF
Yes Yes
Competitive Matrix: AT-AR450S -v- other manufacturers MANUFACTURER MODEL
Allied Telesyn AR450S
Cisco 831
Cisco 1751
Cisco 1721
IP Multicast Routing Support IPX Support PIM/SM/DM DVMRP IPv6 Routing OSI Routing
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes No Yes
Security AES Encryption Support IPSec, DES, 3DES
Yes Yes
Available as software upgrade ‘03 Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
TACACS, RADIUS PAP/CHAP
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Fault Tolerance PSU/MTBF Base MTBF
150,000 hours 533,000 hours
IPSec Network Address Translation (NAT)
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Ethernet VLAN Support 802.1Q
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Management Features CLI (Command Line Interface) Web GUI RMON SNMP
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes RMON lite (groups & events) Yes
Yes Yes RMON lite (groups & events) Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Security SSL Firewall HTTP Proxy
Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes
AS/NRZ 3548 Class A, Class B, FCC Part 15 Class B, EN60555-2 Class B, EN55022 Class B, VCCI Class II, CISPR-22 Class B
FCC Part 15, Class A, EN55022 (CISPR22, Class A) CE Mark
FCC Part 15, Subpart B, Class A, EN50024, EN55022A 1998, CISPR 22 Class A 1985, EN61000-3-2, EN61000-3-3, EN55024 1998
Approvals and Compliance Emissions
Nokia IP380
Nokia IP530
Yes Yes Yes
Yes Yes Yes
Yes Working at Layer 3, IPSec includes specification for ESP, AH IKE etc. Radius
Working at Layer 3, IPSec includes specification for ESP, AH IKE etc. Radius
Watchguard Firebox® V60L
DES, 3DES RADIUS, TACACS, TACACS+ PAP
514,526 hours
Yes
EMC Emissions: EN55052 Class A, FCC Class A, VCCI Class A, AS/NZS CISPR22 Class A
Yes
Immunity
EN55024
IEC 1000-4-2 (EN61000-4-2), IEC 1000-4-3 (ENV 50140), IEC 1000-4-4 (EN 61000-4-4)
55082-1 Generic Immunity Specification Part 1: Residential and Light Industry, IEC 1000-4-2 (EN61000-4-2), IEC 1000-4-3 (ENV50140), IEC 1000-4-4 (EN61000-4-5), IEC 1000-4-6 (ENV501141), IEC 1000-4-11, IEC 1000-3-2
Safety
UL60950, CAN/CSA-C22.2NO, 60950-00
UL1950/CSA950-95 Third Edition, IEC950 Second Edition with amendments 1,2,3 and and 4, CS-03 Canadian Telecom, FCC Part 68 US Telecom requirement, AS/NZS 3260 1996 with amendments 1,2,3 and 4, ETSI 300-047, TS001 with amendment 1, EMI, AS/NRZ 3548 1992 Class B, CFR 47 Part 15 Class B, EN60555-2 Class B, EN55022 Class B, VCCI Class II, ICES-003 Issue 2 Class B April 1997S, IEC 1000-3-2
UL1950, 3rd Edition, CSA 22.2 No 90-95, 3rd Edition, EN60950 with A1 through A4 and A11. EN 41003, TCA TS001-1997, AS/NZS 3260 with A1 through A4, IEC 60950, NOM-019-SCFI, GB4943, ETSI-300-047, BS6301 (PSU) EMI. AS/NRZ 3548 Class B, CNS 13438, FCC Part 15 Class B, EN 6055-2 Class B
UL1950, CSA 22.2 - No 950, EN60950, EN41003, Austel TS001, AS/NZS 3260, ETSI 300-047, BSI 6301 (power supply)
UL1950, CE Mark, CUL/CAS 22.2 No 950-M93, IE950, TUV EN60950
UL195, CAN/CSA 22.2, No 950-M95, (CE Mark), EN60950:1992, A1, A2:1993, A3:1995, A4:1997, A11:1998 with Japanese National Deviations.
Date compiled
Mar 03
Mar 03
Mar 03
Mar 03
Mar 03
Mar 03
Mar 03
