Transcript
Published online January 14, 2004 !"#$!!% !"#$%&# '#&() *%)%+,#-. /001. 23$4 5/. !34 6 789: 60460;5<=+,<>?-6@1
!"#$%&' ( &"") *"+ ,"-#(+./0 1.")"0.,() 2314 /%&5"+627 ,"++%)(&./0 #+"&%./ #+"#%+&.%2 5.&8 &"#")"0.,() 2&(&.2&.,2 9(.:3(/ ;37 <.("5%. =837 >"? @+%%/1(3-7 A"8/ B(++" (/C D(+6 @%+2&%./E !"#$%&'"(& )* +),"-.,$% /0)#1230-3 $(4 /0)-1"'03&%25 677 810&("2 9:"(."5 ;$," <(0:"%30&25 => /)? 6@ABBC5 D"E F$:"(5 GH @7I6@5 -&)O"% 6M5 6@@MN 9--"#&"4 D):"'O"% B65 6@@M
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
./,"-#)%&%/%22 "* &8% %O#%+.-%/&()): C%&%+-./%C :%(2& ./&%+(,&."/ /%&5"+6K Q$!IT>UJ!QT$ !"#$%&'()"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#', )-*. * "#-% &' '%*"-. *-- %/%'$, $0*$ $*1% )-*+% &' * +%--2 3' &4)#"$*'$ &5%*6 &' 7*+$6 %4%"8&'8 &' )#,$98%'#4&+ :&#-#8. &, $0*$ $0% +%-- +*' :% ;'5%",$##5 *, * +#4)-%< '%$=#"1 #7 &'$%"*+$&'8 )"#$%&', >?6@A2 B0% ,%$ #7 *-,;+0 &'$%"*+$&#', +*""&%5 #;$ :. )"#$%&', %'+#5%5 &' * 8%'#4% 0*, :%%' 5;::%5 $0% &'$%"*+$#4%2 C#4)-%< '%$=#"1, *"% *-,# ;,%5 $# 5%,+"&:% $0% ,$";+$;"% #7 * ';4:%" #7 =&5%9"*'8&'8 ,.,$%4, &'+-;5&'8 $0% &'$%"'%$6 )#=%" 8"&5,6 $0% %+#-#8&+*7##5 =%: *'5 ,+&%'$&D+ +#--*:#"*$&#',2 E%,)&$% $0% ,%%4&'8-. 0;8% 5&77%"%'+%, *4#'8 $0%,% ,.,$%4,6 &$ 0*, :%%' ,0#=' $0*$ $0%. *-- ,0*"% +#44#' 7%*$;"%, &' $%"4, #7 '%$=#"1 $#)#-#8. >F(??A2 B0;,6 '%$=#"1, 4*. )"#/&5% * 7"*4%=#"1 7#" 5%,+"&:&'8 :&#-#8. &' * ;'&/%",*- -*'8;*8% ;'5%",$*'5*:-% $# * :"#*5 *;5&%'+%2 !"#$%&' (")*+#+%*, -*( #."%&+", B0% $#)#-#8&+*- *'*-.,&, #7 $0% '%$=#"1, )"#/&5%, G;*'$&$*$&/% &',&80$ &'$# $0%&" :*,&+ #"8*'&H*$&#'2 I#;" $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+, #7 )*"$&+;-*" &'$%"%,$ &' '%$=#"1 *'*-.,&, *"% *, 7#--#=, >F(??A2 >&A 3/%"*8% 5%8"%% >JA2 B0% 5%8"%% #7 * '#5% &, $0% ';4:%" #7 -&'1, $0*$ $0&, '#5% 0*, =&$0 #$0%" '#5%,2 B0% */%"*8% 5%8"%% #7 $0% =0#-% '%$=#"1 &, $0% */%"*8% #7 $0% 5%8"%%, #7 *-- &$, &'5&/&5;*- '#5%,2 >&&A C-;,$%"&'8 +#%7D+&%'$ >CA2 B0&, &, 5%D'%5 *, $0% "*$&# #7 $0% ';4:%" #7 %<&,$&'8 -&'1, :%$=%%' * '#5%K, '%&80:#", *'5 $0% 4*<&4;4 )#,,&:-% ';4:%" #7 -&'1, :%$=%%' $0%4 >,&4&-*" $# *' #55, "*$&#A2 B0% +-;,$%"&'8 +#%7D+&%'$ #7 * '%$=#"1 &, $0% */%"*8% #7 *-- &$, &'5&/&5;*+#%7D+&%'$,2 B0&, ,$*$&,$&+ +*' :% ;,%5 $# 5%$%"4&'% $0% +#4)-%$%'%,, #7 $0% '%$=#"12 >&&&A C0*"*+$%"&,$&+ )*$0 -%'8$0 >LA2 B0% 8"*)09$0%#"%$&+*- 5&,$*'+% :%$=%%' $=# '#5%, &, $0% 4&'&4;4 ';4:%" #7 %58%, $0*$ &, '%+%,,*". $# $"*/%",% 7"#4 #'% '#5% $# $0% #$0%"2 B0% +0*"*+$%"&,$&+ )*$0 -%'8$0 #7 * '%$=#"1 &, $0% */%"*8% #7 $0%,% 4&'&4;4 5&,$*'+%,2 M$ 8&/%, * 4%*,;"% #7 0#= +-#,%-. '#5%, *"% +#''%+$%5 =&$0&' $0% '%$=#"12 >&/A E&*4%$%" >EA2 B0% 5&*4%$%" #7 * '%$=#"1 &, $0% -#'8%,$ 8"*)09$0%#"%$&+*- 5&,$*'+% :%$=%%' *'. $=# '#5%, &' $0% 8"*)02 B*:-% ? %<)-*&',6 &' 5%$*&-6 $0% 7#"4;-*, $0*$ *"% ;,%5 $# +*-+;-*$% $0%,% ,$*$&,$&+,2
NB# =0#4 +#""%,)#'5%'+% ,0#;-5 :% *55"%,,%52 B%-O P? @QF RF@ S?QTU I*-E) ,%)%,D%(
Downloaded from nar.oxfordjournals.org at Albert R. Mann Library on November 11, 2010
FGH!IFJ!
!"#$%&# '#&() *%)%+,#-. /001. 23$4 5/. !34 6
!"&
4-50" 67 i/%"/&%= #7 $0% &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$*,%$, *'5 $0% *'*-.,&,O $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+, f*4%
d.4:#-
3/%"*8% 5%8"%%
J
I;'+$&#' !
?&
&!f
!
C-;,$%"&'8 +#%7D+&%'$
C0*"*+$%"&,$&+ )*$0 -%'8$0
C
L
!
@%& ? "? & & # ?$ &!f @%
! !
(&j
E%,+"&)$&#'
\%,;-$,*
?&O 5%8"%% #7 '#5% & &O &$0 '#5% !O $#$*- ';4:%" #7 '#5%,
@V2@
%&O ';4:%" #7 %58%, %<&,$&'8 :%$=%%' $0% ?& '#5%, $0*$ +#''%+$%5 $# '#5% &
Q2?Vg
(&jO ,0#"$%,$ )*$0 -%'8$0 :%$=%%' '#5% & *'5 '#5% N
F2TF
&! j ! f
!"! # ?$ E
4*< k(&jU &6 N # !l
^*<&4*- ,0#"$%,$ 5&,$*'+% :%$=%%' *'. $=# '#5%,
?Q
!#=%"9-*= 5&,$"&:;$&#'
* $
G>?A m *?($
?O 5%8"%% G>?AO )"#:*:&-&$. #7 D'5&'8 * '#5% =&$0 5%8"%% ? *O &'$%"+%)$&#' #' n *<&, #' * -#8(-#8 )-#$ $O ,-#)% #7 $0% 5&,$"&:;$&#' #' * -#8(-#8 )-#$
* m @QgW $ m (?2F@
*B0%
/*-;%, #7 $0% $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+, 7#" $0% =0#-% .%*,$ &'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"12
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`6 4%*'&'8 $0*$ &$ &, /%". ;'-&1%-. $0*$ $0%"% =&-- :% *'. '#5%, #7 5%8"%% ,&8'&D+*'$-. -*"8%" $0*' */%"*8%2 B# %<)-*&' $0% 0%$%"#8%'%#;, '*$;"% #7 +#4)-%< '%$=#"1,6 a*"*:*],& *'5 +#--%*8;%, "%+%'$-. )"#)#,%5 * b,+*-%97"%%K 4#5%- &' =0&+0 $0% 5%8"%% 5&,$"&:;$&#' &' 4*'. -*"8% '%$=#"1, 7#--#=, * )#=%"9-*= _G>?A " ?K,` >F6TA2 3 "%4*"1*:-% )#&'$ *:#;$ $0&, 5&,$"&:;$&#' &, $0*$ 4#,$ #7 $0% '#5%, =&$0&' $0%,% '%$=#"1, 0*/% /%". 7%= -&'1,6 =&$0 #'-. * 7%= #7 $0%4 >0;:,A :%&'8 0&80-. +#''%+$%52 ^*'. *,)%+$, #7 8%'#4&+ :&#-#8. 0*/% ,;+0 * ,+*-%97"%% ,$";+$;"% >?F(?WA2 C#'+;""%'$-.6 c*$$, *'5 d$"#8*$H 7#;'5 $0*$ 4*'. '%$=#"1, +*' *-,# :% 5%,+"&:%5 *, 0*/&'8 * b,4*--9=#"-5K )"#)%"$. >??A6 &2%2 $0%. *"% 5%D'%5 *, :%&'8 :#$0 0&80-. +-;,$%"%5 *'5 +#'$*&'&'8 ,4*-- +0*"*+$%"&,$&+ )*$0 -%'8$0, >-*"8% C *'5 ,4*-- LA2 C#4)-%< '%$=#"1,6 4#"%#/%"6 +*' :% 7;"$0%" 5&/&5%5 &'$# $=# :"#*5 +*$%8#"&%,O 5&"%+$%5 *'5 ;'5&"%+$%52 M' *' ;'5&"%+$%5 '%$=#"16 $0% ,$*$%4%'$ b'#5% 3 &, -&'1%5 $# '#5% aK &, $0% ,*4% *, b'#5% a &, -&'1%5 $# '#5% 3K2 e#=%/%"6 $0% %58%, #7 $0% 5&"%+$%5 '%$=#"1, 0*/% * 5%D'%5 5&"%+$&#'2 B0;,6 $0% +-;,$%"&'8 +#%7D+&%'$ +*''#$ :% +*-+;-*$%5 7#" 5&"%+$%5 '%$=#"1, >SA2 /+%0%1+2-0 -330+2-#+%*, C;""%'$-.6 -*"8%9,+*-% %<)%"&4%'$, 0*/% +"%*$%5 * 8"%*$ /*"&%$. #7 8%'#4%9=&5% &'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"1,6 %,)%+&*--. &' L+##-+,3MF#%) #%,%D&)&+% >?V(@?A2 I;"$0%"4#"%6 $0%"% *"% *-,# * ';4:%" #7 5*$*:*,%, _&2%2 ^M!d >@@A6 aMfE >@FA *'5 EM! >@RA` $0*$ 0*/% 4*'. 4*';*--. +;"*$%5 &'$%"*+$&#', 7#" .%*,$2
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gA2 d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f%$6 $# )%"7#"4 +#4)*"&,#', *;$#4*$&+*--.2 M$ &, */*&-*:-% 7"#4O 0$$)Ohh8%'%+%',;,2#"8h B#)f%$2 B#)f%$ $*1%, *' *":&$"*". ;'5&"%+$%5 '%$=#"1 *'5 * 8"#;) #7 '#5% +-*,,%, *, *' &');$ $# +"%*$% ,;:9'%$=#"1,2 B0%' &$ +#4);$%, *-- 7#;" $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+, 4%'$&#'%5 *:#/% *'5 5"*=, * )#=%"9-*= 5%8"%% 5&,$"&:;$&#' 7#" %*+0 ,;:9'%$=#"12 B0% "%,;-$, #7 $0%,% +*-+;-*$&#', *"% )-#$$%5 &' $0% ,*4% 7#"4*$ 7#" %*+0 ,$*$&,$&+ $# 7*+&-&$*$% 5&"%+$ +#4)*"&,#'2 B#)f%$ *-,#
Downloaded from nar.oxfordjournals.org at Albert R. Mann Library on November 11, 2010
E&*4%$%"
!!'
!"#$%&# '#&() *%)%+,#-. /001. 23$4 5/. !34 6
4-50" ;7 i/%"/&%= #7 $0% &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$*,%$, *'5 $0% *'*-.,&,O :&#-#8&+*- +*$%8#"&%, \%7%"%'+%
Z\L
f#2 i\I, +#/%"%5
f#2 #7 8"#;),
X<)"%,,&#'
>RWA
0$$)Ohh?W?2ST2@S2T@h.%*,$o+%--o+.+-%h+%--+.+-%20$4-
S?FQ
?F
!"#$%&' ,&H%
>RVA
0$$)Ohh===2.%*,$8%'#4%2#"8h
SQg@
?@
34&'# *+&5 +#4)#,&$&#'
>FFA
0$$)Ohh;,2%<)*,.2#"8h$##-,h),+*-%h!#-*"&$.p"*'$0*420$4-
SQg@
?R
d;:+%--;-*" -#+*-&H*$&#' I;'+$&#'
>RgA >@@A
0$$)Ohh:&#&'7#24::2.*-%2%5;h8%'#4%h-#+*-&H%h 0$$)Ohh4&),28,725%h)"#jh.%*,$hCnpEh5:h&'5%<20$4-
@gQ@ FgFS
R @
d%G;%'+% +#',%"/*$&#' B%"$&*". ,$";+$;"% >7#-5A I#-5 +-*,, d%+#'5*". ,$";+$;"% d#-;:-% )"#$%&' /%",;, 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&'
>TQA >T?A >T?A >R?A >RQA
0$$)Ohh===2'+:&2'-42'&028#/hCiph 0$$)Ohh,+#)24"+9-4:2+*42*+2;1h,+#)h 0$$)Ohh,+#)24"+9-4:2+*42*+2;1h,+#)h 0$$)Ohh*:,2+&$2'&028#/h8#"h 0$$)Ohh===2+:,25$;251h,%"/&+%,hB^e^^h
R?Fg FRW? FRW? SQg@ SQg@
T RT@ W W ?R
E%,+"&)$&#' C%--9+.+-% %<)"%,,&#' 5*$* ;,&'8 *77.4%$"&< E%"&/%5 7"#4 8%'#4% ,%G;%'+% E%"&/%5 7"#4 8%'#4% ,%G;%'+% $"*',)#,#' $*88&'8 ^M!d I;'+$&#'*+*$*-#8, Cip 5*$*:*,% dCi! 5*$*:*,% dCi! 5*$*:*,% !"%5&+$%5 :. pi\ Mq !"%5&+$%5 :. B^e^^ ,%"/%" / @2Q
4-50" <7 i/%"/&%= #7 $0% &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$*,%$, *'5 $0% *'*-.,&,O &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$*,%$, E*$*,%$
\%7%"%'+%
Z\L
f#2 i\I, +#/%"%5
f#2 #7 &'$%"*+9 $&#',
^M!d +#4)-%< +*$*-#8, aMfE EM! n%*,$ $=#90.:"&5 n%*,$ $=#90.:"&5
>@@A >@FA >@RA >?VA >@?A
VW? FWVg RW?S F@WV ?QRR
V@TQ TgST ?T??F RFgF gV?
9= D&D3 );--95#=' 9= D&D3 );--95#='
>@QA >?gA
0$$)Ohh4&),28,725%h)"#jh.%*,$hCnpEh5:h&'5%<20$40$$)Ohh===2:&'52+*h 0$$)Ohh5&)25#%94:&2;+-*2%5;h5&)h^*&'2+8& 0$$)Ohh8%'#4%2+21*'*H*=*9;2*+2j)hn@eh 0$$)Ohh===2'*$;"%2+#4h+8&9$*7hE.'*!*8%2$*7rD-%mh'*$;"%h j#;"'*-h/RQFh'SWWQh7;--hRQFS@F*Qo7,20$40$$)Ohh.%*,$2+%--H#4%2+#4h 0$$)Ohh===245,)2+#4h.%*,$h
?FS? ?TWV
F?FQR @TFFF
%'*:-%, $0% ;,%" $# %<)-#"% +#4)-%< '%$=#"1, :. ,%+$&#',2 I#" %<*4)-%6 *-- '%&80:#", #7 * +%"$*&' '#5% +*' :% ,0#=' #' * ,&4)-% 8"*)02 3-$%"'*$&/%-.6 $0% ;,%" +#;-5 ,%-%+$ $=# '#5%, *'5 "%G;%,$ $0*$ *-- )*$0, '#$ %<+%%5&'8 ,#4% ,)%+&D%5 -%'8$0 :% 5&,)-*.%5 *, *' &'5%)%'5%'$ 8"*)02 c% &44%5&*$%-. *))-&%5 B#)f%$ $# $0% */*&-*:-% &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$* *'5 * ';4:%" #7 &4)#"$*'$ ,$";+$;"*- *'5 7;'+$&#'*+-*,,%, 7#" .%*,$ )"#$%&',6 =0&+0 *"% ,;44*"&H%5 &' B*:-%, @( F2 B0% "%,;-$, "%/%*- ,%/%"*- &'$%"%,$&'8 "%-*$&#',0&), :%$=%%' * )"#$%&'K, :&#-#8&+*- )"#)%"$&%, *'5 &$, $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+, =&$0&' $0% &'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"12 c% +0#,% $0% "%,;-$, #7 ,%/%"*4#,$ &'$%"%,$&'8 *'5 &4)#"$*'$ )"#$%&' +-*,,%, 7#" 7;"$0%" 5&,+;,,&#' :%-#=2 I#" #$0%" "%,;-$,6 )-%*,% D'5 $0%4 $0"#;80 $0% b5#='-#*5K )*8% #' $0% B#)f%$ =%:,&$%2
IVHUW!H F$> >QHJUHHQT$ 89"&9+"$ %: 4%3!"# B#)f%$ +#',&,$, #7 7#;" 4*j#" )*"$, >,%% I&82 ?A2 CI$3+(4 M' $0% D",$ ,$%) >*, ,0#=' &' I&82 ?6 b;)-#*5KA6 $0% ;,%" +*' ;)-#*5O >&A * ,%$ #7 %58%, *'5 >&&A >#)$&#'*--.A 5&77%"%'$ ,;:9 8"#;), #7 '#5%,2 B0% '%$=#"1 4;,$ :% ;'5&"%+$%52 B0% 8"#;), *"% 5%D'%5 *, $0% +-*,,%, #7 $0% '#5%, &7 $0% '%$=#"1 &, +#4)#,%5 #7 ;'&G;% ,;:9)#);-*$&#',2
3 /*"&%$. #7 ,*4)-% '%$=#"1, *"% */*&-*:-% 7"#4 $0% =%:,&$%2 B0&, &'+-;5%, * +#4)"%0%',&/% .%*,$ &'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"1 *'5 4*'. )#,,&:-% +-*,,%, #7 .%*,$ )"#$%&',2 a%+*;,% $0% .%*,$ &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$* )"#5;+%5 :. 5&77%"%'$ 4%$0#5, 5&77%" &' 4*'. *,)%+$, >@VA6 =% *-,# 5&/&5%5 $0% .%*,$ '%$=#"1 &'$# $0"%% )*"$,O >&A 5*$* )"#5;+%5 :. &'5&/&5;*- %<)%"&4%'$, >+#4)&-%5 7"#4 ^M!d6 aMfE *'5 EM! 5*$*:*,%, >@@(@RAU $0% "%,;-$, 7"#4 $0% -*"8%9,+*-% %<)%"&4%'$, *"% %<+-;5%5AU >&&A 5*$* )"#5;+%5 :. -*"8%9,+*-% .%*,$ $=#90.:"&5 %<)%"&4%'$, >?V6@?AU >&&&A 5*$* )"#5;+%5 :. &= D&D3 );--95#=' %<)%"&4%'$, >?g6@QA2 !"%5&+$%5 #" -&$%"*$;"%95%"&/%5 &'$%"*+$&#', +*' *-,# :% ;)-#*5%52 O+$#"$+E&3=4 3, ,0#=' &' I&8;"% ?6 b+*-+;-*$&#'K6 B#)f%$ *;$#4*$&+*--. +#4);$%, $0% 7#;" $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+, 5%9 ,+"&:%5 *:#/%2 B0% "%,;-$, *"% )"%,%'$%5 &' * $*:-% 7#" %*,. 5#='-#*5&'8 *'5 &' 8"*)0, 7#" 5&"%+$ /&,;*-&H*$&#'2 a%+*;,% 4*'. "%*- '%$=#"1, *"% ,+*-%97"%%6 $0% 5%8"%% 5&,$"&:;$&#', 7#" 5&77%"%'$ +-*,,%, *"% )-#$$%5 #' * -#8(-#8 ,+*-%2 B0% 5%8"%% 5&,$"&:;$&#' #7 ,+*-%97"%% '%$=#"1, 7#--#=, * )#=%"9-*=6 &2%2 $0% 5&,$"&:;$&#' &, * ,$"*&80$ -&'% #' * -#8(-#8 )-#$2 B0% )*"*4%$%", *'5 $0% +#""%-*$&#' +#%7D+&%'$, #7 $0% "%8"%,,&#' -&'%, *"% *-,# 8&/%' #' $0% 8"*)02 !+D&>+E&3=4 3, ,0#=' &' I&8;"% ?6 b'*/&8*$&#'K6 B#)f%$ %<)-#"%, $0% '%$=#"1, '#5% :. '#5%6 ,0#=&'8 *-- $0% '%&80:#",
Downloaded from nar.oxfordjournals.org at Albert R. Mann Library on November 11, 2010
C*$%8#".
!"#$%&# '#&() *%)%+,#-. /001. 23$4 5/. !34 6
!!(
#7 %*+0 '#5% *, 4#,$ #7 $0% "%*- '%$=#"1, *"% $## +#4)-%< $# 5&,+%"' *'. &'7#"4*$&#' 7"#4 * 8-#:*- /&%=2 d)%+&D+*--.6 &' $0% .%*,$ )"#$%&'()"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"1 %<*4)-%6 5&77%"9 %'$ +#-#", *"% ;,%5 $# &'5&+*$% $0% ,#;"+%, #7 $0% &'$%"*+$&#' :%$=%%' * 8&/%' '#5% *'5 $0% +%'$%" '#5%2 M'$%"*+$&#', $0*$ *"% +#'D"4%5 :. ,%/%"*- &'5%)%'5%'$ 4%$0#5, 0*/%' :%%' ,0#=' $# :% #7 0&80%" G;*-&$. >@gA2 B#)f%$ +*' $0;, 7*+&-&$*$% $0% 5%$%"4&'*$&#' #7 "%-&*:-% &'$%"*+$&#' )*"$'%", #7 * ,)%+&D+ 8%'% 7#" ;,% &' 7;"$0%" &'/%,$&8*$&#'2 2&)"+$&P+E&3=4 I&'*--.6 *, 5&,+;,,%5 *:#/%6 &$ &, 0*"5 $# 5%)&+$ $0% =0#-% '%$=#"1 +-%*"-.2 3-$0#;80 &$ &, ;,%7;- $# ,0#= *-- $0% '%&80:#", #7 %*+0 '#5%6 $0% ;,%" ,#4%$&4%, =*'$, $# 5&"%+$-. /&%= $0% $#)#-#8. #7 * ,;:9'%$=#"16 =0%"% $0% )"#$%&', $0*$ $0% ;,%" &, &'$%"%,$%5 &' *"% &'/#-/%52 Z,&'8 B#)f%$6 $0% ;,%" +#;-5 ,)%+&7. $=# '#5%, *'5 * 4*<&4;4 )*$0 -%'8$02 B0%' $0% $##- =&-- ,0#= *-- )#,,&:-% )*$0, +#''%+$&'8 $0%,% '#5%, >*, ,0#=' &' I&82 ?6 b/&,;*-&H*$&#'KA =&$0 -%'8$0 -%,, $0*' $0% ,)%+&D%5 4*<&4;42 =01%&+#.>, +* 4%3!"# 7&)E+=#% #+$#"$+E&3=4 B# +*-+;-*$% $0% 5&*4%$%" *'5 $0% +0*"*+$%"&,$&+ )*$0 -%'8$0 #7 %*+0 '%$=#"1 >#" ,;:9'%$=#"1A6 5&,$*'+%, :%$=%%' *'. $=# +#''%+$%5 '#5%, >5&,+#''%+$%5 '#5%, *"% %<+-;5%5A *"% +*-+;-*$%5 D",$ :. * 8"%%5. *-8#"&$042
d&4)-. );$6 7#" %*+0 ,#;"+% '#5%6 *-- #7 &$, '%&80:#", *"% -*:%-%5 *, 0*/&'8 * 5&,$*'+% #7 ?2 B0% '#5%, $0*$ *"% -&'1%5 $# $0%,% '%&80:#", *"% -*:%-%5 *, 0*/&'8 * 5&,$*'+% #7 @6 *'5 ,# #'6 ;'$&- $0% D'*- '#5% &, %'+#;'$%"%52 f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a. ,+#"&'8 %*+0 '#5% =&$0 &$, ,0#"$%,$ 5&,$*'+% 7"#4 :#$0 ,#;"+% *'5 $*"8%$6 =% +*' ;,% $0% "%-*$&#' :%$=%%' $0% ,+#"%, #7 * '#5% *'5 $0% ,+#"%, #7 &$, '%&80:#", $# &5%'$&7. %58%, #' * ,0#"$%,$ )*$0 &' $&4% )"#)#"$&#'*- $# $0% ';4:%" #7 %58%, &' $0% 8"*)02 O-3&#%) &= %MQ%((&=> + )"QR=%ES3,? &= $+,>%, =%ES3,?4 B0% );")#,% #7 B#)f%$ &, $# *--#= $0% "%,%*"+0%" $# 5&/&5% $0% '%$=#"1 #7 &'$%"%,$ &'$# 4*'. ,;:9'%$=#"1,6 *'5 $0%' +#4)*"% $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+, #7 $0#,% ,;:9'%$=#"1,2 e#=%/%"6 $0% &,,;% #7 %4:%55&'8 * ,;:9'%$=#"1 &'$# * :&88%" '%$=#"1 0*, *
Downloaded from nar.oxfordjournals.org at Albert R. Mann Library on November 11, 2010
?+1@&" 67 i/%"/&%= #7 B#)f%$2 B0% =0#-% =%:,&$% +#',&,$, #7 7#;" 4*j#" )*"$,O ;)-#*56 +*-+;-*$&#'6 '*/&8*$&#' *'5 /&,;*-&H*$&#'2 I#" 5%$*&-,6 )-%*,% "%7%" $# $0% $%<$2
!!"
!"#$%&# '#&() *%)%+,#-. /001. 23$4 5/. !34 6
=330+2-#+%*A -*-0B,+, %: (+::"&"*# 1"*%>+2 :"-#@&", +* B"-,# M' * 5&"%+$ 7*,0&#'6 =% +*' *))-. B#)f%$ $# $0% %<&,$&'8 &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$*,%$, *'5 ,$*'5*"5 ,%$, #7 )"#$%&' +-*,,%, */*&-*:-% 7#" .%*,$2 B0&, %'*:-%, ;, $# D'5 ,#4% ,$"*&80$7#"9 =*"5 :;$ &'$%"%,$&'8 :&#-#8&+*- +#""%-*$&#',2 M' )*"$&+;-*" =% 7#+;,%5 #' $0% 7#--#=&'8 +0*"*+$%"&,$&+,O >&A 4\f3 %<)"%,9 ,&#'6 >&&A *4&'# *+&5 +#4)#,&$&#'6 >&&&A ,#-;:&-&$.6 >&/A ,%+#'59 *". ,$";+$;"%6 >/A 7;'+$&#' *'5 >/&A )"#$%&' ,&H%2 M' #"5%" $# )%"7#"4 * +#4)-%$% *'*-.,&, #7 $0% =0#-% .%*,$ &'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"16 =% 4%"8%5 *-- $0% */*&-*:-% )"#$%&'( )"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$*,%$, $# +"%*$% * +#4)"%0%',&/% '%$=#"1
?+1@&" ;7 3 +%"$*&' ,;:9'%$=#"1 &, %4:%55%5 &' $0% =0#-% '%$=#"16 =0%' $0% $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+, 7#" $0% '#5%, &' $0&, ,;:9'%$=#"1 *"% +*-+;-*$%52 >=A f#5% ) &'$%"*+$, =&$0 $0"%% #$0%" '#5%, &' ,;:9'%$=#"1 ' >,0#=' *, ,#-&5 +&"+-%,A *'5 #'% '#5% &' ,;:9'%$=#"1 T >,0#=' *, #)%' +&"+-%,A2 B0% 5%8"%% #7 ) &, $0%"%7#"% R &',$%*5 #7 F2 >/A B0% ,0#"$%,$ )*$0 :%$=%%' '#5%, ) *'5 E +#;-5 8# $0"#;80 '#5%, &' ,;:9'%$=#"1 T >,0#=' *, $0% 8"%%' -&'%A2 B0;,6 $0% 5&,$*'+% :%$=%%' ) *'5 E &, @6 '#$ F2
?+1@&" <7 \%-*$&#',0&), :%$=%%' %<)"%,,&#' -%/%-, *'5 $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+,2 >=A !"#$%&'K, */%"*8% 5%8"%% 0*, *' %<)#'%'$&*- "%-*$&#',0&) =&$0 &$, %<)"%,,&#' -%/%-2 B0% "%8"%,,&#' %G;*$&#'6 *@ *'5 G /*-;% *"% ,0#=' &' $0% D8;"%2 B0% G /*-;% 4%*,;"%, $0% ,$*$&,$&+*- ,&8'&D+*'+% #7 $0% +#""%-*$&#' #7 "%8"%,,&#' _*`2 >/A !"#$%&'K, %<)"%,,&#' -%/%- 0*, * )#,&$&/% "%-*$&#',0&) =&$0 &$, +-;,$%"&'8 +#%7D+&%'$2 >C *'5 DA !"#$%&'K, %<)"%,,&#' -%/%- 0*, * '%8*$&/% "%-*$&#',0&) =&$0 &$, 5&*4%$%" *'5 +0*"*+$%"&,$&+ )*$0 -%'8$02
Downloaded from nar.oxfordjournals.org at Albert R. Mann Library on November 11, 2010
';4:%" #7 +#4)-%<&$&%,2 B# "%,#-/% $0%,% +#4)-%<&$&%, =% 0*/% $# 4*1% * ';4:%" #7 *":&$"*". :;$ "%*,#'*:-% 5%+&,&#',2 C#',&5%" $0% +*-+;-*$&#' #7 '#5% 5%8"%% >* ,$%) #' $0% =*. $# +*-+;-*$&'8 $0% */%"*8% '#5% 5%8"%% #7 * ,;:9'%$=#"1A2 d;))#,% '#5% ) &' ,;:9'%$=#"1 ' 0*, $0"%% '%&80:#", *-,# &' '6 *'5 #'% '%&80:#" $0*$ &, '#$ &' '2 E# =% +*-+;-*$% $0% 5%8"%% #7 ) *, $0"%% #" 7#;"r L&1%=&,%6 +#',&5%" $0% )"#:-%4 #7 +*-+;-*$&'8 $0% ,0#"$%,$ 5&,$*'+% :%$=%%' $=# '#5%, &' $0% ,*4% ,;:9'%$=#"1 >* '%+%,,*". ,$%) &' +*-+;-*$&'8 * ,;:9 '%$=#"1K, 5&*4%$%"A2 c0*$ 5# =% 5# &7 $0% ,0#"$%,$ )*$0 4*1%, ;,% #7 '#5%, '#$ &' $0% ,;:9'%$=#"1r c% 0*/% 5%+&5%5 $# +*-+;-*$% $0%,% /*-;%, >*, =%-- *, *'*-#8#;, /*-;%, 7#" $0% +-;,$%"&'8 +#%7D+&%'$A =&$0 "%,)%+$ $# $0% %'$&"% '%$=#"12 B0&, &, &--;,$"*$%5 &' I&8;"% @2 d# 7#" $0% %<*4)-%, *:#/% =% +*-+;-*$% $0% 5%8"%% *, 7#;"6 *'5 =% 5# ;,% * )*$0 &'/#-/&'8 $0% '#5%, #;$,&5% $0% ,;:9'%$=#"12 3, =% *"% ;-$&4*$%-. &'$%"%,$%5 &' $0% ,$*$&,$&+, #7 $0% ,;:9'%$=#"1, *, $0%. "%-*$%5 $# $0% '%$=#"1 *, * =0#-%6 &$ =*, -#8&+*- $# 8# &' $0&, 5&"%+$&#'2
!"#$%&# '#&() *%)%+,#-. /001. 23$4 5/. !34 6
!!!
?+1@&" F7 \%-*$&#',0&), :%$=%%' */%"*8% 5%8"%% *'5 )"#$%&' )#-*"&$.6 *'5 ,#-;:&-&$.2 >=A !"#$%&' )#-*"&$. &, 5%$%"4&'%5 *, $0% */%"*8% )#-*"&$. #7 *-&$, +#4)#,&'8 *4&'# *+&5,2 !"#$%&', *"% :&''%5 &'$# ?R 8"#;), =&$0 *))"#<&9 4*$%-. $0% ,*4% ';4:%" #7 )"#$%&', &' %*+0 8"#;)2 B0% G /*-;%6 +*-+;-*$%5 :. $0% ^*''(c0&$'%. $%,$ >* '#'9)*"*4%$"&+ U $%,$A >RSA6 4%*,;"%, $0% 5&77%"%'+% :%$=%%' $0% )"#$%&' 8"#;), #7 0&80%,$ *'5 -#=%,$ )#-*"&$&%,2 >/A B0% ';4:%" #7 $"*',94%4:"*'% 0%-&+%, &, )"%5&+$%5 :. B^e^^ ,%"/%" @2Q2 B0% -*:%-, #' $0% A9*<&,O d6 d#-;:-% )"#$%&',U $0% ';4:%" 4%*', 5&77%"%'$ +-*,,%, #7 )"#$%&', =&$0 +#""%,)#'5&'8 ';4:%" #7 $"*',94%4:"*'% 0%-&+%,U !?F6 *-- $0% )"#$%&', =&$0 !?F $"*',94%4:"*'% 0%-&+%,2 B0% G /*-;%6 +*-+;-*$%5 :. $0% ^*''(c0&$'%. $%,$6 4%*,;"%, $0% 5&77%"%'+% :%9 $=%%' ,#-;:-% *'5 $"*',94%4:"*'% )"#$%&',6 =0&+0 +#',&,$, #7 *-- $0% )"#$%&', =&$0 $"*',94%4:"*'% 0%-&+%,2
7#" .%*,$ >,%% B*:-% FA6 =0&+0 +#',&,$, #7 SgTg@ &'$%"*+$&#', *4#'8 RgTW )"#$%&', >@gA2 p&/%' $0% 0&80 7*-,% )#,&$&/% "*$%, #7 4*'. #7 $0% 0&809$0"#;80);$ &'$%"*+$&#' ,+"%%' 4%$0#5, >@VA6 =% 5&/&5%5 $0&, =0#-% &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$*,%$ &'$# $0"%% ,;:9 5*$*,%$, >*, 5%,+"&:%5 *:#/%A $# 7;"$0%" +#'D"4 $0% :&#-#8&+*"%-%/*'+% #7 $0% "%,;-$,2 >&A B=#90.:"&5 ,;:95*$*,%$6 =0&+0 +#'$*&', *-- $0% &'$%"*+$&'8 )*&", &5%'$&D%5 :. .%*,$ $=#90.:"&5 %<)%"&4%'$, >T@Q@ &'$%"*+$&#',6 W2Ts #7 $0% $#$*-A >?V6@?A2 >&&A !;--95#=' ,;:95*$*,%$6 =0&+0 +#'$*&', *-- $0% &'$%"*+$&#', &5%'$&D%5 :. &= D&D3 );--95#=' $%+0'&G;%, >TR SSF &'$%"9 *+$&#',6 WV2Ts #7 $0% $#$*-A >?g6@QA2 >&&&A ^*';*- ,;:95*$*,%$6 =0&+0 +#'$*&', &'$%"*+$&'8 )"#$%&' )*&", &5%'$&D%5 :. &'5&/&59 ;*- %<)%"&4%'$, 7"#4 ^M!d6 aMfE *'5 EM! >&'$%"*+$&'8 )*&", &' $0% D",$ $=# ,;:95*$*,%$, *"% %<+-;5%5U ?R VFW &'$%"*+$&#',6 @?2Fs #7 $0% $#$*-A >@@(@RA2 B0% $=#90.:"&5 ,;:95*$*,%$ &, 1'#=' $# +#'$*&' 4*'. 7*-,% )#,&$&/%, >@VA *'5 &$ &, t?Qs #7 #;" =0#-% 5*$*,%$2 B0%"%7#"%6 $0% "%,;-$, 7"#4 $0% $=#90.:"&5 ,;:95*$*,%$ *"% '#$ *, "%-&*:-% *, $0% 4*';*- ,;:95*$*,%$6 =0&+0 &, 8%'%"*--. :%-&%/%5 $# :% $0% 4#,$ "%-&*:-% 5*$* */*&-*:-% >@VA2 B0;,6 &7 $0% "%,;-$ +*-+;-*$%5 :*,%5 #' $0% 4*';*- ,;:95*$*,%$ *8"%%, =&$0 $0*$ #7 $0% =0#-% 5*$*,%$6 =% :%-&%/% $0*$ $0% "%,;-$ &, 4#"% $";,$=#"$0. $0*' &7 +*-+;-*$%5 *8*&',$ $0% $=#90.:"&5 ,%$2 c%
"%)%*$%5 *-- $0% +*-+;-*$&#', #' $0%,% $0"%% ,;:95*$*,%$, &'5&/&5;*--.6 )%"7#"4&'8 * ,&4)-% 7#"4 #7 ,%',&$&/&$. *'*-.,&,2 c&$0 #'% %<+%)$&#'6 $0% "%,;-$, *"% &' ,$"#'8 *8"%%4%'$2 i'-. $0#,% "%,;-$, )%"$*&'&'8 $# )"#$%&' ,&H% *"% 5&77%"%'$6 *, 5&,+;,,%5 &' 5%$*&- :%-#=2 M*!' %AI,%))&3=4 d$*"$&'8 =&$0 * "%7%"%'+% 5*$*,%$ 7#" $0% *:,#-;$% %<)"%,,&#' -%/%- &' .%*,$ _* '#'9$"&/&*- +#4:&'*$&#' #7 5&77%"%'$ 8%'% %<)"%,,&#' 5*$*,%$, >F?A` =% ;,%5 B#)f%$ $# &'/%,$&8*$% "%-*$&#',0&), :%$=%%' %<)"%,,&#' -%/%-, *'5 $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+, #7 $0% '%$=#"1 #7 1'#=' &'$%"*+$&'8 .%*,$ )"#$%&',2 B0% )"#$%&', *"% 5&/&5%5 &'$# ?F 8"#;), :*,%5 #' $0%&" %<)"%,,&#' -%/%-,2 3, ,0#=' &' I&8;"% F6 ,;:9'%$=#"1, +#',&,$&'8 #7 0&80-. %<)"%,,%5 )"#$%&', $%'5 $# 0*/% 0&80%" */%"*8% 5%8"%%, *'5 +-;,$%"&'8 +#%7D+&%'$,6 :;$ ,4*--%" 5&*4%$%", *'5 +0*"*+$%"&,$&+ )*$0 -%'8$0,2 e#=%/%"6 ,#4% +#""%-*$&#', >I&82 Fa(EU ,$*$&,$&+, C6 L *'5 E6 "%,)%+$&/%-.A *"% /%". )##"U $0%"%7#"%6 =% 7#+;,%5 #;" *'*-.,&, ,)%+&D+*--. #' "%-*$&#',0&), :%$=%%' $0% )"#$%&'K, :&#-#8&+*- )"#)%"$&%, *'5 &$, 5%8"%% 5&,$"&:;$&#' 7#" *-- :&#-#8&+*- 7%*$;"%,2 M' I&8;"% F36 $0% +;"/% ,0#=, *' %<)#'%'$&*- 5&,$"&:;$&#'2 B0&, "%,;-$ 4*1%, ,%',%U )"#$%&', =&$0 4#"% +#)&%, &' $0% +%-0*/% * 8"%*$%" )#,,&:&-&$. #7 &'$%"*+$&'8 =&$0 #$0%" )"#$%&', :. +0*'+% *-#'%6 *-$0#;80 $0% 4\f3 -%/%- *'5 $0% *:;'5*'+% #7 * )"#$%&' 5# '#$ *-=*., +#""%-*$% )%"7%+$-. >F@A2 c% *-,# -##1%5 *$ $0% "%-*$&#',0&) :%$=%%' %<)"%,,&#' u;+$;*$&#' >&2%2 $0"#;80 $0% .%*,$ +%-- +.+-%A *'5 $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+,6 :;$ 5&5 '#$ D'5 *'. ,$"#'8 +#""%-*$&#', >,%% $0% b5#='-#*5K )*8%A2 'M&=3 +#&( #3MI3)&E&3=4 3, ,0#=' &' I&8;"% R36 )"#$%&', =&$0 4#"% )#-*" *4&'# *+&5, $%'56 #' */%"*8%6 $# 0*/% 0&80%" 5%8"%%, &' $0% &'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"12 _B0% )#-*"&$. #7 * )"#$%&' +*' :% 5%$%"4&'%5 7"#4 $0% */%"*8% #7 $0% )#-*"&$&%, #7 &$, *4&'# *+&5, ;,&'8 $0% p"*'$0*4 ,+*-% >FFA2 3 ,&4&-*" 4%$0#5 0*, :%%' ;,%5 $# +*-+;-*$% $0% 0.5"#)0#:&+&$. #7 )"#$%&', >FRA`2 B0"%% 4*j#" "%*,#', 7#" $0&, )0%'#4%'#' +#;-5 :%O >&A )#-*" *4&'# *+&5, $%'5 $# :% #' $0% )"#$%&'K, ,;"7*+% >FTA6 $0%"%7#"% $0% 4#"% )#-*" *4&'# *+&5, * )"#$%&' 0*,6 $0% -*"8%" $0% ,;"7*+%
Downloaded from nar.oxfordjournals.org at Albert R. Mann Library on November 11, 2010
?+1@&" E7 X<)%+$%5 *'5 #:,%"/%5 7"%G;%'+&%, #7 $0% 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&', *'5 $0% &'$%"*+$&#', :%$=%%' 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&', &' $0% .%*,$ 8%'#4%2 bX^K6 %<)%+$%5 7"%G;%'+. #7 $0% 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&',U bi^K6 #:,%"/%5 7"%G;%'+. #7 $0% 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&',U bXMK6 %<)%+$%5 7"%G;%'+. #7 $0% &'$%"*+$&#', :%$=%%' 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&',U biMK6 #:,%"/%5 7"%G;%'+. #7 $0% &'$%"*+$&#', :%$=%%' 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&',2
!!)
!"#$%&# '#&() *%)%+,#-. /001. 23$4 5/. !34 6
G,3E%&= )3$"Q&$&EF4 M' 8%'%"*-6 ,#-;:-% )"#$%&', 0*/% 4*'. 4#"% &'$%"*+$&#' )*"$'%", $0*' 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&', >,%% I&82 Ra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e^^ ,%"/%" @2Q >RQA2 L%#3=(+,F )E,"#E",%4 B0% ,%+#'5*". ,$";+$;"% #7 )"#$%&', =*, )"%5&+$%5 ;,&'8 $0% pi\ Mq *-8#"&$04 >R?A2 M$ &, #:/&#;, 7"#4 I&8;"% S $0*$ 4#"% 0%-&+*- )"#$%&', $%'5 $# 0*/% 4#"% &'$%"*+$&#',2 3 8##5 %<*4)-% #7 $0% &'/#-/%4%'$ #7 0%-&+%, &' &'$%"*+$&#', &, +#&-%59+#&- 5#4*&',6 =0&+0 +#',&,$ #7 $=# #" 4#"% *-)0*90%-&+%, $0*$ ="*) *"#;'5 %*+0 #$0%" =&$0 * ,-&80$ -%7$90*'5%5 ,;)%"0%-&+*- $=&,$ >R@6RFA2 M' $0% .%*,$ 8%'#4%6 ?@? )"#$%&', +#'$*&'&'8 +#&-%59+#&- "%8&#', =%"% &5%'$&D%5 ;,&'8 $0% ^ZLBMCiML *-8#"&$04 >RRA2 M' $0% =0#-% &'$%"9 *+$&#' 5*$*,%$6 $0%"% *"% @TQ &'$%"*+$&'8 )*&", *4#'8 ??g #7 $0%,% ?@? )"#$%&',2
?+1@&" G7 \%-*$&#',0&), :%$=%%' */%"*8% 5%8"%% *'5 )"#$%&' ,%+#'5*". ,$";+$;"%,2 B0% ,%+#'5*". ,$";+$;"%, #7 )"#$%&', *"% 5%$%"4&'%5 :. $0% pi\ Mq *-8#"&$042 B0% 7"*+$&#' >&2%2 $0% A9*<&,A &, +*-+;-*$%5 *, $0% "*$&# #7 $0% ';4:%" #7 *4&'# *+&5, =&$0 * +%"$*&' ,%+#'5*". ,$";+$;"% #/%" $0% $#$*-%'8$0 #7 $0% )"#$%&'2 !"#$%&', *"% :&''%5 &'$# ,%/%' 8"#;), =&$0 *))"#<&9 4*$%-. $0% ,*4% ';4:%" #7 )"#$%&', &' %*+0 8"#;)2 B0% G /*-;% &' >=A6 +*-9 +;-*$%5 :. $0% ^*''(c0&$'%. $%,$6 4%*,;"%, $0% 5&77%"%'+% :%$=%%' $0% )"#$%&' 8"#;), #7 0&80%,$ *'5 -#=%,$ 7"*+$&#' #7 0%-&+%,2 B0% "%8"%,,&#' %G;*$&#',6 *@ *'5 G /*-;%, *"% ,0#=' &' >/A *'5 >CA2 B0% G /*-;%, 4%*,;"% $0% ,$*$&,$&+*- ,&8'&D+*'+% #7 $0% +#""%-*$&#' #7 "%8"%,,&#' _*`2
V"=#E&3=4 c% *-,# #:,%"/%5 * /%". &'$%"%,$&'8 )0%'#4%'#' &' $0% %<)%"&4%'$*--. 5%$%"4&'%5 &'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"1O )"#$%&', =&$0 *$ -%*,$ #'% 7;'+$&#'*- *''#$*$&#' &' ^M!d 5*$*:*,% >@@A #' */%"*8% 0*5 * 4;+0 0&80%" 5%8"%% $0*' $0#,% =&$0#;$ *'. 7;'+$&#'*- *''#$*$&#' >I&82 WA2 B0&, "%u%+$, $0% :&*, &' +;""%'$ &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$*,%$,6 &2%2 )"#$%&', =&$0 7;'+$&#'*- *''#$*$&#' *"% )"%7%""%5 *, :*&$,6 %/%' &' -*"8%9,+*-% %<)%"&4%'$,2 B0% +*-+;-*$&#', 7#" $0% *:#/% D/% +0*"*+$%"&,$&+, 0*/% :%%' "%)%*$%5 7#" $0% $0"%% ,;:95*$*,%$,2 B0% "%,;-$, "%4*&' $0%
Downloaded from nar.oxfordjournals.org at Albert R. Mann Library on November 11, 2010
&$ +#;-5 )#$%'$&*--. 0*/%2 >&&A i'% #7 $0% 4#,$ &4)#"$*'$ )"#$%&'()"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#' 7#"+%, &, %-%+$"#,$*$&+,2 !#-*" *4&'# *+&5, 0*/% * 0&80%" $%'5%'+. $# 0*/% $0&, 1&'5 #7 &'$%"*+$&#' >FSA2 !"%/&#;, ,$;5&%, 0*/% ,0#=' $0*$6 *-$0#;80 #/%"*-- &'$%"*+$&#' &'$%"7*+%, *"% 0.5"#)0#:&+6 )#-*" *4&'# *+&5 "%,&5;%, *"% +#',%"/%5 *$ ,)%+&D+ )#,&$&#', *, &'$%"*+$&#' b0#$ ,)#$,K >FWA2 >&&&A ^#,$ )"#$%&', =&$0#;$ 4*'. )#-*" *4&'# *+&5, *"% 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&',2 a%+*;,% #7 $0% &'0%"%'$ :&*, *8*&',$ 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&', &' $0% %<)%"&4%'$*--. 5%$%"4&'%5 &'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"16 4%4:"*'% )"#$%&', 0*/% -%,, &'$%"*+$&#' )*"$'%",6 *, =&-- :% 5&,+;,,%5 &' 5%$*&- :%-#=2 M' .%*,$ $=#90.:"&5 %<)%"&4%'$,6 )"#$%&' :*&$, 0*/% Ef39 :&'5&'8 5#4*&', *'5 $0% )"%., 0*/% $0% *+$&/*$&#' 5#4*&',2 c0%' $0% )"#$%&' :*&$, &'$%"*+$ =&$0 $0% )"%.,6 $0% &'$%"*+$&#' =&-- :"&'8 $0% *+$&/*$&#' 5#4*&' $# $0% Ef39:&'5&'8 5#4*&'6 =0&+0 =&-- $;"' #' $0% "%)#"$%" 8%'%,2 e#=%/%"6 ,#4% )#-*" )"#$%&' :*&$, 0*/% *+$&/*$&#' 5#4*&'9-&1% *+&5&+ "%8&#',2 M$ 0*, :%%' ,0#=' $0*$ $0%,% )#-*" )"#$%&' :*&$, +#;-5 $;"' #' $0% "%)#"$%" 8%'%, &' $0% *:,%'+% #7 *'. )"%., >FV6FgA2 B0%"%7#"%6 )#-*" )"#$%&', 4&80$ )"#5;+% 4*'. 7*-,% )#,&$&/% ,&8'*-, *'5 *"$&D+&*--. 0*/% 4#"% &'$%"*+$&#' )*"$'%",2 e#=%/%"6 =% )%"7#"4%5 $0% ,*4% +*-+;-*$&#', #' $0% $0"%% ,;:95*$*,%$, *'5 $0% "%,;-$, "%4*&' $0% ,*4%2 ^#,$ &4)#"$*'$-.6 $0% "%,;-$ :*,%5 #' $0% 4*';*- ,;:95*$*,%$ +#'D"4, $0*$ $0% +#""%-*$&#' :%$=%%' )"#$%&' )#-*"&$. *'5 &$, 5%8"%% &, "%*-2
!"#$%&# '#&() *%)%+,#-. /001. 23$4 5/. !34 6
,*4% >,%% d;))-%4%'$*". ^*$%"&*-6 I&8, ?(WA6 =0&+0 +#'D"4, $0*$ $0%. *"% "%-&*:-% *'5 7"%% #7 *"$&7*+$, #7 -*"8%9,+*-% &'$%"*+$&#' ,+"%%' 4%$0#5,2
,&8'*-2 >&&A ^#,$ &4)#"$*'$-.6 &' I&8;"% V $0% )"#$%&', *"% 5&/&5%5 &'$# ?@ :&', :*,%5 #' $0%&" -%'8$0,U %*+0 :&' +#'$*&', *))"#<&4*$%-. TQQ )"#$%&',2 a%+*;,% #7 $0% '*$;"% #7 $0% &= D&D3 );--95#=' $%+0'&G;% >&2%2 &5%'$&7.&'8 +#4)-%<%, &',$%*5 #7 :&'*". &'$%"*+$&'8 )*&",A6 $0% */%"*8% 5%8"%% #7 $0% )"#$%&', &' $0&, ,;:95*$*,%$ >RW2gA &, 4;+0 0&80%" $0*' $0#,% #7 $0% #$0%" $=# ,;:95*$*,%$, >@2g 7#" $0% $=#90.:"&5 ,;:,%$6 S2S 7#" $0% 4*';*- ,;:,%$A2 B0%"%7#"%6 $0% */%"*8% 5%8"%% #7 %*+0 :&' &' I&8;"% V 5%)%'5, #' $0% ';4:%" #7 )"#$%&', &' $0% :&' $0*$ *"% &'+-;5%5 &' $0% );--95#=' ,;:,%$2 B0% 7*+$ $0*$ $0%"% *"% 7%= ,4*-- )"#$%&', &' $0% );--95#=' ,;:9
?+1@&" H7 !"#$%&', =&$0 *$ -%*,$ #'% 7;'+$&#'*- *''#$*$&#' 0*/% 4*'. 4#"% &'$%"*+$&#' )*"$'%", $0*' $0#,% =&$0#;$ *'. 7;'+$&#'*- *''#$*$&#', :*,%5 #' ^M!d 7;'+$&#'*- +-*,,&D+*$&#'2 B0% G /*-;%6 +*-+;-*$%5 :. $0% ^*''( c0&$'%. $%,$6 4%*,;"%, $0% 5&77%"%'+% :%$=%%' $0% $=# 8"#;),2
?+1@&" I7 \%-*$&#',0&), :%$=%%' */%"*8% 5%8"%% *'5 )"#$%&' -%'8$02 !"#$%&' -%'8$0 &, "%u%+$%5 &' $0% ';4:%" #7 *4&'# *+&5, &$ 0*,2 >=A !#,&$&/% "%-*$&#',0&) &' $0% =0#-% 5*$*,%$2 >/A f%8*$&/% "%-*$&#',0&) &' $0% 4*';*- ,;:95*$*,%$2 >CA f# ,&8'&D+*'$ "%-*$&#',0&), &' $0% );--95#=' ,;:95*$*,%$2 >DA !#,&$&/% "%-*$&#',0&) &' $0% $=#90.:"&5 ,;:95*$*,%$2 B0% "%8"%,,&#' %G;*$&#'6 *@ *'5 G /*-;% *"% ,0#=' &' >3A6 >CA *'5 >EA2 B0% G /*-;% 4%*,;"%, $0% ,$*$&,$&+*,&8'&D+*'+% #7 $0% +#""%-*$&#' #7 "%8"%,,&#' _*`2
Downloaded from nar.oxfordjournals.org at Albert R. Mann Library on November 11, 2010
G,3E%&= )&P%4 B# #;" ,;")"&,%6 $0% "%,;-$, #7 #;" *-8#"&$04, *, *))-&%5 $# 5&77%"%'$ 5*$*,%$, 5# '#$ *8"%% =&$0 %*+0 #$0%" =&$0 "%,)%+$ $# )"#$%&' ,&H% >,%% I&82 VA2 M' $0% =0#-% 5*$*,%$6 =% 7#;'5 $0*$ -*"8%" )"#$%&', $%'5 $# 0*/% 4#"% &'$%"*+$&#' )*"$'%", >,%% I&82 V3A2 d;:,%G;%'$-.6 =% "%)%*$%5 $0% +*-+;-*$&#', #' $0% $0"%% ,;:95*$*,%$, &'5&/&5;*--.O >&A 4*';*,;:95*$*,%$ >,%% I&82 VaA2 !"#$%&' ,&H% 0*, * '%8*$&/% "%-*$&#',0&) =&$0 )"#$%&' 5%8"%%6 &2%2 $0% -*"8%" $0% )"#$%&' &,6 $0% -%,, &'$%"*+$&#' )*"$'%", &$ 0*, #' */%"*8%2 >&&A );--95#=' ,;:95*$*,%$ >,%% I&82 VCA2 B0%"% *"% '# ,$"#'8 "%-*$&#',0&), :%$=%%' )"#$%&' ,&H% *'5 5%8"%%2 >&&&A $=#90.:"&5 ,;:95*$*,%$ >,%% I&82 VEA2 !"#$%&' ,&H% 0*, * )#,&$&/% "%-*$&#',0&) =&$0 )"#$%&' 5%8"%%6 &2%2 $0% -*"8%" $0% )"#$%&' &,6 $0% 4#"% &'$%"*+$&#' )*"$'%", &$ 0*, #' */%"*8%6 =0&+0 *8"%%, =&$0 $0% "%,;-$ #7 $0% =0#-% &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$*,%$2 3, 5&,+;,,%5 %*"-&%"6 $0% 4*';*- ,;:95*$*,%$ &, $0% 4#,$ "%-&*:-% 5*$*,%$ >@VA6 *'5 $0% "%,;-$ +*-+;-*$%5 :*,%5 #' $0&, ,;:95*$*,%$ *8"%%, =%-- =&$0 #;" +#44#' 1'#=-%58%6 &2%2 ,#4% #7 $0% 4#,$ )"#4&,+;#;, )"#$%&', *"% ,4*-- ;',)%+&D+ "%)%*$, ,;+0 *, ;:&G;&$&' >RTA2 B0% )#,&$&/% "%-*$&#',0&) #:,%"/%5 &' $0% $=#90.:"&5 ,;:9 5*$*,%$ *'5 $0% =0#-% 5*$*,%$ *"% 8%'%"*$%5 :. $0% 7#--#=&'8 *"$&7*+$,2 >&A M' .%*,$ $=#90.:"&5 %<)%"&4%'$,6 ,#4% -*"8% )"#$%&', 4*. '#$ :% *:-% $# 7#-5 +#""%+$-. &' * '#'9'*$&/% %'/&"#'4%'$ >&2%2 ';+-%;,A2 B0%. 4&80$ $0%' %<)#,% 0.5"#9 )0#:&+ 8"#;), *'5 *88"%8*$%6 )"#5;+&'8 * 7*-,% )#,&$&/%
!!*
!!+
!"#$%&# '#&() *%)%+,#-. /001. 23$4 5/. !34 6
5*$*,%$ -%*5, $# $0% *"$&D+&*- )#,&$&/% "%-*$&#',0&) #:,%"/%5 &' $0% =0#-% 5*$*,%$ >,%% d;))-%4%'$*". ^*$%"&*-6 I&82 VA2 J@>>-&B
HUXXWVDV$!FI; DF!VIQFW d;))-%4%'$*". ^*$%"&*- &, */*&-*:-% *$ f3\ i'-&'%2 FJB$TRWV>@VDV$!H B0% *;$0#", =#;-5 -&1% $# $0*'1 $0% "%7%"%%, 7#" &',&80$7;+#44%'$, $0*$ 0%-)%5 &4)"#/% $0% 4*';,+"&)$2 ^2p2 *+1'#=9 -%58%, ,;))#"$ 7"#4 $0% fMehfMp^d p^QTR?SQ9QW2 IVPVIV$JVH ?2 X&,%':%"86E26 ^*"+#$$%6X2^26 v%'*"&#,6M2 *'5 n%*$%,6B2i2 >@QQQA !"#$%&' 7;'+$&#' &' $0% )#,$98%'#4&+ %"*2 !+E",%6 FKE6 V@F(V@S2 @2 e*"$=%--6L2e26 e#)D%-56w2w26 L%&:-%"6d2 *'5 ^;""*.632c2 >?gggA I"#4 4#-%+;-*" $# 4#5;-*" +%-- :&#-#8.2 !+E",%6 FK;6 CRW(T@2 F2 a*"*:*,&632L2 *'5 3-:%"$6\2 >?gggA X4%"8%'+% #7 ,+*-&'8 &' "*'5#4 '%$=#"1,2 L#&%=#%6 ;IG6 TQg(T?@2 R2 3-:%"$6\26 w%#'86e2 *'5 a*"*:*,&632L2 >?gggA E&*4%$%" #7 $0% c#"-59 c&5% c%:2 !+E",%6 FK66 ?FQ(?F?2 T2 3-:%"$6\26 w%#'86e2 *'5 a*"*:*,&632L2 >@QQQA X""#" *'5 *$$*+1 $#-%"*'+% #7 +#4)-%< '%$=#"1,2 !+E",%6 FKG6 FWV(FV@2 S2 3-:%"$6\2 *'5 a*"*:*,&632L2 >@QQ@A d$*$&,$&+*- 4%+0*'&+, #7 +#4)-%< '%$=#"1,2 *%D4 W3(4 G-F)46 HF6 RW(gW2 W2 34*"*-6L2326 d+*-*6326 a*"$0%-%4.6^2 *'5 d$*'-%.6e2X2 >@QQQA C-*,,%, #7 ,4*--9=#"-5 '%$=#"1,2 G,3#4 !+E$ '#+(4 L#&4 CL'6 LH6 ???Rg(???T@2 V2 p&"/*'6^2 *'5 f%=4*'6^2X2 >@QQ@A C#44;'&$. ,$";+$;"% &' ,#+&*- *'5 :&#-#8&+*- '%$=#"1,2 G,3#4 !+E$ '#+(4 L#&4 CL'6 LL6 WV@?(WV@S2 g2 e;:%"4*'6a232 *'5 35*4&+6L232 >?gggA p"#=$0 5.'*4&+, #7 $0% c#"-59c&5% c%:2 !+E",%6 FK66 ?F?2 ?Q2 w%#'86e26 ^*,#'6d2!26 a*"*:*,&632L2 *'5 i-$/*&6x2f2 >@QQ?A L%$0*-&$. *'5 +%'$"*-&$. &' )"#$%&' '%$=#"1,2 !+E",%6 F666 R?(R@2 ??2 c*$$,6E2w2 *'5 d$"#8*$H6d2e2 >?ggVA C#--%+$&/% 5.'*4&+, #7 b,4*--9 =#"-5K '%$=#"1, !+E",%6 ?gTgA i' "*'5#4 8"*)0, M2 G"Q$4 W+E-46 G6 @gQ(@gW2 ?F2 y&*'6w26 L;,+#4:%6f2^2 *'5 p%",$%&'6^2 >@QQ?A !"#$%&' 7*4&-. *'5 7#-5 #++;""%'+% &' 8%'#4%,O )#=%"9-*= :%0*/&#;" *'5 %/#-;$&#'*". 4#5%-2 X4 W3$4 T&3$46 <6<6 SWF(SV?2 ?R2 L;,+#4:%6f2^26 y&*'6w26 x0*'86x26 w#0',#'6B2 *'5 p%",$%&'6^2 >@QQ@A B0% 5#4&'*'+% #7 $0% )#);-*$&#' :. * ,%-%+$%5 7%=O )#=%"9-*= :%0*/&#;" *))-&%, $# * =&5% /*"&%$. #7 8%'#4&+ )"#)%"$&%,2 Y%=3M% T&3$46 <6 \XdX3\CeQQRQ2 ?T2 \H0%$,1.632 *'5 p#4%H6d2^2 >@QQ?A a&"$0 #7 ,+*-%97"%% 4#-%+;-*" '%$=#"1, *'5 $0% ';4:%" #7 5&,$&'+$ Ef3 *'5 )"#$%&' 5#4*&', )%" 8%'#4%2 T&3&=B3,M+E&#)6 6H6 gVV(ggS2 ?S2 e*""&,#'6!2^2 *'5 p%",$%&'6^2 >@QQ@A d$;5.&'8 8%'#4%, $0"#;80 $0% *%#',O )"#$%&' 7*4&-&%,6 ),%;5#8%'%, *'5 )"#$%#4% %/#-;$&#'2 X4 W3$4 T&3$46 <6I6 ??TT(??WR2
Downloaded from nar.oxfordjournals.org at Albert R. Mann Library on November 11, 2010
M' ,;44*".6 =% 0*/% 8&/%' *' #/%"/&%= #7 $0% 5%,&8' )"&'+&)-%, *'5 * =&5% "*'8% #7 )#,,&:-% *))-&+*$&#', #7 #;" *;$#4*$%5 =%: $##-O B#)f%$2 B0&, $##- )"#/&5%, ;,%", =&$0 $0% *:&-&$. $# +#4)*"% $0% $#)#-#8&+*- ,$*$&,$&+, #7 5&77%"%'$ ,;:9 )#);-*$&#', =&$0&' $0% ,*4% '%$=#"1 *'5 $# %<)-#"% +#4)-%< '%$=#"1, )*"$ :. )*"$2 B# 5%4#',$"*$% &$, ;,%6 =% *))-&%5 B#)f%$ $# *'*-.H% $0% "%-*$&#',0&), :%$=%%' * /*"&%$. #7 :&#-#8&+*- +-*,,%, *'5 * )"#$%&'K, 5%8"%% 5&,$"&:;$&#' =&$0&' $0% .%*,$ )"#$%&'()"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"12 B0% "%,;-$, &--;,9 $"*$%5 ,%/%"*- &'$%"%,$&'8 $"%'5,6 =0&+0 +#;-5 :% ;,%5 $# )"%5&+$ )"#$%&'()"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#', *'5 ;-$&4*$%-. )"#$%&' 7;'+$&#'2 I;"$0%"4#"%6 #;" *'*-.,%, *-,# 5&,+#/%"%5 ,%/%"*- ,.,$%4*$&+ %""#", %<&,$&'8 &' $0% +;""%'$ -*"8%9,+*-% &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$*2
?W2 J##'&'6X2q26 c#-76n2M2 *'5 J*"%/6p2!2 >@QQ@A B0% ,$";+$;"% #7 $0% )"#$%&' ;'&/%",% *'5 8%'#4% %/#-;$&#'2 !+E",%6 F;K6 @?V(@@F2 ?V2 M$#6B26 B*,0&"#6J26 ^;$*6d26 iH*=*6\26 C0&:*6B26 f&,0&H*=*6^26 n*4*4#$#6J26 J;0*"*6d2 *'5 d*1*1&6n2 >@QQQA B#=*"5 * )"#$%&'9)"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#' 4*) #7 $0% :;55&'8 .%*,$O * +#4)"%0%',&/% ,.,$%4 $# %<*4&'% $=#90.:"&5 &'$%"*+$&#', &' *-- )#,,&:-% +#4:&'*$&#', :%$=%%' $0% .%*,$ )"#$%&',2 G,3#4 !+E$ '#+(4 L#&4 CL'6 LH6 ??RF(??RW2 ?g2 e#6n26 p";0-%"6326 e%&-:;$6326 a*5%"6p2E26 ^##"%6L26 35*4,6d2L26 ^&--*"6326 B*.-#"6!26 a%''%$$6J26 a#;$&-&%"6J2 %E +$4 >@QQ@A d.,$%4*$&+ &5%'$&D+*$&#' #7 )"#$%&' +#4)-%<%, &' L+##-+,3MF#%) #%,%D&)&+% :. 4*,, ,)%+$"#4%$".2 !+E",%6 F6E6 ?VQ(?VF2 @Q2 p*/&'632C26 a#,+0%6^26 J"*;,%6\26 p"*'5&6!26 ^*"H&#+06^26 a*;%"6326 d+0;-$H6w26 \&+16w2^26 ^&+0#'632^26 C";+&*$6C2^2 %E +$4 >@QQ@A I;'+$&#'*- #"8*'&H*$&#' #7 $0% .%*,$ )"#$%#4% :. ,.,$%4*$&+ *'*-.,&, #7 )"#$%&' +#4)-%<%,2 !+E",%6 F6E6 ?R?(?RW2 @?2 Z%$H6!26 p&#$6L26 C*8'%.6p26 ^*',D%-56B2326 w;5,#'6\2d26 J'&80$6w2\26 L#+1,0#'6E26 f*"*.*'6q26 d"&'&/*,*'6^26 !#+0*"$6!2 %E +$4 >@QQQA 3 +#4)"%0%',&/% *'*-.,&, #7 )"#$%&'9)"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#', &' L+##-+,3MF#%) #%,%D&)&+%2 !+E",%6 FK<6 S@F(S@W2 @@2 ^%=%,6e2c26 I"&,04*'6E26 p;-5%'%"6Z26 ^*''0*;)$6p26 ^*.%"6J26 ^#1"%j,6^26 ^#"8%',$%"'6a26 ^;',$%"1#$$%"6^26 \;556d2 *'5 c%&-6a2 >@QQ@A ^M!dO * 5*$*:*,% 7#" 8%'#4%, *'5 )"#$%&' ,%G;%'+%,2 !"#$%&# '#&() *%)46 @QQFA aMfEO $0% a#-%+;-*" M'$%"*+$&#' f%$=#"1 E*$*:*,%2 !"#$%&# '#&() *%)46 <66 @RV(@TQ2 @R2 v%'*"&#,6M26 d*-=&',1&6L26 E;*'6v2w26 e&8'%.6!26 J&46d2^2 *'5 X&,%':%"86E2 >@QQ@A EM!6 $0% E*$*:*,% #7 M'$%"*+$&'8 !"#$%&',O * "%,%*"+0 $##- 7#" ,$;5.&'8 +%--;-*" '%$=#"1, #7 )"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#',2 !"#$%&# '#&() *%)46 @QQ@A C#4);$*$&#'*- 4%$0#5, 7#" $0% )"%5&+$&#' #7 )"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#',2 O",,4 8I&=4 LE,"#E4 T&3$46 6;6 FSV(FWF2 @S2 I"&%54*'6C26 J"*6!26 n;6e26 J"*;$0*44%"6^2 *'5 \H0%$,1.632 >@QQ?A pXfMXdO * '*$;"*-9-*'8;*8% )"#+%,,&'8 ,.,$%4 7#" $0% %<$"*+$&#' #7 4#-%+;-*" )*$0=*., 7"#4 j#;"'*- *"$&+-%,2 T&3&=B3,M+E&#)6 6H >d;))- ?A6 dWR(V@2 @W2 L%%6B2M26 \&'*-5&6f2w26 \#:%"$6I26 i5#46E2B26 a*"9w#,%)06x26 p%":%"6p2J26 e*''%$$6f2^26 e*":&,#'6C2B26 B0#4),#'6C2^26 d&4#'6M2 %E +$4 >@QQ@A B"*',+"&)$&#'*- "%8;-*$#". '%$=#"1, &' L+##-+,3MF#%) #%,%D&)&+%2 L#&%=#%6 ;LI6 Wgg(VQR2 @V2 /#' ^%"&'86C26 J"*;,%6\26 d'%-6a26 C#"'%--6^26 i-&/%"6d2p26 I&%-5,6d2 *'5 a#"16!2 >@QQ@A C#4)*"*$&/% *,,%,,4%'$ #7 -*"8%9,+*-% 5*$* ,%$, #7 )"#$%&'9)"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#',2 !+E",%6 F6H6 Fgg(RQF2 @g2 w*',%'6\26 L*'6f26 y&*'6w2 *'5 p%",$%&'6^2 >@QQ@A M'$%8"*$&#' #7 8%'#4&+ 5*$*,%$, $# )"%5&+$ )"#$%&' +#4)-%<%, &' .%*,$2 X4 LE,"#E4 V"=#E4 Y%=3M&#)6 ;6 W?(V?2 FQ2 X5=*"5,632^26 J;,6a26 w*',%'6\26 p"%%':*;46E26 p"%%':-*$$6w2 *'5 p%",$%&'6^2 >@QQ@A a"&58&'8 ,$";+$;"*- :&#-#8. *'5 8%'#4&+,O *,,%,,&'8 )"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#' 5*$* =&$0 1'#=' +#4)-%<%,2 U,%=() Y%=%E46 6I6 T@g(TFS2 F?2 p"%%':*;46E26 w*',%'6\2 *'5 p%",$%&'6^2 >@QQ@A 3'*-.,&, #7 4\f3 %<)"%,,&#' *'5 )"#$%&' *:;'5*'+% 5*$*O *' *))"#*+0 7#" $0% +#4)*"&,#' #7 $0% %'"&+04%'$ #7 7%*$;"%, &' $0% +%--;-*" )#);-*$&#' #7 )"#$%&', *'5 $"*',+"&)$,2 T&3&=B3,M+E&#)6 6I6 TVT(TgS2 F@2 p"%%':*;46E26 L;,+#4:%6f2^26 w*',%'6\26 y&*'6w2 *'5 p%",$%&'6^2 >@QQ?A M'$%""%-*$&'8 5&77%"%'$ $.)%, #7 8%'#4&+ 5*$*6 7"#4 )"#$%#4% $# ,%+"%$#4%O K#4&'8 &' #' 7;'+$&#'2 Y%=3M% *%)46 666 ?RSF(?RSV2 FF2 p"*'$0*46\2 >?gWRA 34&'# *+&5 5&77%"%'+% 7#"4;-* $# 0%-) %<)-*&' )"#$%&' %/#-;$&#'2 L#&%=#%6 6IE6 VS@(VSR2 FR2 w#'%,6d2 *'5 B0#"'$#'6w2^2 >?ggSA !"&'+&)-%, #7 )"#$%&'9)"#$%&' &'$%"*+$&#',2 G,3#4 !+E$ '#+(4 L#&4 CL'6 L<6 ?F(@Q2 FT2 B*1*'#6J26 n*4*8*$*6n2 *'5 n;$*'&6J2 >@QQ?A C#'$"&:;$&#' #7 )#-*" 8"#;), &' $0% &'$%"&#" #7 * )"#$%&' $# $0% +#'7#"4*$&#'*- ,$*:&-&$.2 T&3#-%M&)E,F6 FK6 RVTF(RVTV2 FS2 v;6E26 L&'6d2L2 *'5 f;,,&'#/6\2 >?ggWA !"#$%&' :&'5&'8 /%",;, )"#$%&' 7#-5&'8O $0% "#-% #7 0.5"#)0&-&+ :"&58%, &' )"#$%&' *,,#+&*$&#',2 X4 W3$4 T&3$46 ;GE6 SV(VR2 FW2 e;6x26 ^*6a26 c#-7,#'6e2 *'5 f;,,&'#/6\2 >@QQQA C#',%"/*$&#' #7 )#-*" "%,&5;%, *, 0#$ ,)#$, *$ )"#$%&' &'$%"7*+%,2 G,3E%&=)6 ?ggVA 3 "*"% +*,% #7 7*-,% )#,&$&/% &' * .%*,$ $=#90.:"&5 ,+"%%'&'8O $0% ,%-%+$&#' #7 "%*""*'8%5 :*&$ +#',$";+$, $0*$ )"#5;+% * 7;'+$&#'*- 8*-R *+$&/&$.2 '=+$4 T&3#-%M46 ;G;6 gR(gS2 Fg2 3-#.6!2 *'5 \;,,%--6\2a2 >@QQ@A !#$%'$&*- *"$%7*+$, &' )"#$%&'9&'$%"*+$&#' '%$=#"1,2 VZTL [%EE46 E@QQ?A !"%5&+$&'8 $"*',4%4:"*'% )"#$%&' $#)#-#8. =&$0 * 0&55%' ^*"1#/ 4#5%-O *))-&+*$&#' $# +#4)-%$% 8%'#4%,2 X4 W3$4 T&3$46 ?ggSA pi\ 4%$0#5 7#" )"%5&+$&'8 )"#$%&' ,%+#'5*". ,$";+$;"% 7"#4 *4&'# *+&5 ,%G;%'+%2 W%E-3() Z=PFM3$46 ;GG6 TRQ(TTF2 R@2 C#0%'6C2 *'5 !*"".6E232 >?ggRA 3-)0*90%-&+*- +#&-%5 +#&-,O 4#"% 7*+$, *'5 :%$$%" )"%5&+$&#',2 L#&%=#%6 ;G<6 RVV(RVg2 RF2 iKd0%*6X2J26 J-%446w2E26 J&46!2d2 *'5 3-:%"6B2 >?gg?A v9"*. ,$";+$;"% #7 $0% pCfR -%;+&'% H&))%"6 * $=#9,$"*'5%56 )*"*--%- +#&-%5 +#&-2 L#&%=#%6 ;EF6 TFg(TRR2 RR2 f%=4*'6w2\26 c#-76X2 *'5 J&46!2d2 >@QQQA 3 +#4);$*$&#'*--. 5&"%+$%5 ,+"%%' &5%'$&7.&'8 &'$%"*+$&'8 +#&-%5 +#&-, 7"#4 L+##-+,3MF#%) #%,%D&)&+%2 G,3#4 !+E$ '#+(4 L#&4 CL'6 LH6 ?F@QF(?F@QV2 RT2 C0*;6q26 B#:&*,6w2c26 a*+04*&"6326 ^*""&#$$6E26 X+1%"6E2w26 p#'5*6E2J2 *'5 q*",0*/,1.632 >?gVgA 3 4;-$&;:&G;&$&' +0*&' &, +#'D'%5 $# ,)%+&D+ -.,&'% &' * $*"8%$%5 ,0#"$9-&/%5 )"#$%&'2 L#&%=#%6 ;F<6 ?TWS(?TVF2
!!%
RS2 \&+%6w2 >?ggRA W+E-%M+E&#+$ LE+E&)E&#) +=( 7+E+ '=+$F)&)2 E;<:;". !"%,,6 a%-4#'$6 C32 RW2 C0#6\2w26 C*4):%--6^2w26 c&'H%-%"6X2326 d$%&'4%$H6L26 C#'=*.6326 c#5&+1*6L26 c#-7,:%"86B2p26 p*:"&%-&*'632X26 L*'5,4*'6E26 L#+10*"$6E2w2 %E +$4 >?ggVA 3 8%'#4%9=&5% $"*',+"&)$&#'*- *'*-.,&, #7 $0% 4&$#$&+ +%-- +.+-%2 W3$4 O%$$6 ;6 ST(WF2 RV2 C0%"".6w2^26 a*--6C26 c%'86d26 w;/&16p26 d+04&5$6\26 35-%"6C26 E;''6a26 E=&80$6d26 \&-%,6L26 ^#"$&4%"6\2J2 %E +$4 >?ggWA p%'%$&+ *'5 )0.,&+*4*), #7 d*++0*"#4.+%, +%"%/&,&*%2 !+E",%6 @QQ@A d;:+%--;-*" -#+*-&H*$&#' #7 $0% .%*,$ )"#$%#4%2 Y%=%) 7%D46 6G6 WQW(W?g2 TQ2 B*$;,#/6\2L26 J##'&'6X2q2 *'5 L&)4*'6E2w2 >?ggWA 3 8%'#4&+ )%",)%+$&/% #' )"#$%&' 7*4&-&%,2 L#&%=#%6 ;HI6 SF?(SFW2 T?2 L# C#'$%6L26 a"%''%"6d2X26 e;::*"56B2w26 C0#$0&*6C2 *'5 ^;"H&'632p2 >@QQ@A dCi! 5*$*:*,% &' @QQ@O "%D'%4%'$, *++#44#5*$% ,$";+$;"*8%'#4&+,2 !"#$%&# '#&() *%)46
